Articles Posted in Long term disability denial

O’Ryan Law Firm, on behalf of our client, Deborah P., recently filed a lawsuit against Madison National after they wrongfully terminated her disability benefits. Our client was employed as a Teacher with the Hanover Community School Corporation, which made her eligible for disability benefits offered through the Hanover Community School Corporation employee benefit plan.  Madison National is often times the insurance company for long term disability coverage offered to most teachers.

Deborah began her teaching career in 1984. After 30 years of teaching, Deborah was forced to stop working in December 2014 due to infiltrating ductal carcinoma, hypothyroid, chronic fatigue syndrome, GERD, neuropathy, knee pain, chest pain, shortness of breath, weakness, edema, nausea, palpations, cardiomyopathy, Hashimoto’s thyroiditis, migraines, and insomnia.

In October 2013, Deborah received a devastating diagnosis of invasive ductal carcinoma stage 2. Her life became overfilled with treatments, doctor visits, tests, decisions on treatments, etc. Since the tumor was almost 5cm, Deborah underwent chemotherapy first to see if the tumor would shrink and offer her more options. Deborah underwent extremely aggressive chemotherapy and continued to teach during treatments in hopes of beating the cancer and returning to teaching full time. Deborah began experiencing pain in her joints, profound fatigue, and was nauseous all the time. In March 2014, Deborah underwent a lumpectomy. Since 3 out of 5 lymph nodes were removed and tested positive, Deborah lives in daily fear that her cancer will return. In addition to chemotherapy and surgery, Deborah also underwent proton radiation. Deborah has tried to return to work, but became too profoundly fatigue to make it through a normal school day.

O’Ryan Law Firm, on behalf of Plaintiff, Dave C., recently filed a lawsuit against a Cigna subsidiary, Life Insurance Company of North America (LINA), after they wrongfully terminated our client’s long term disability benefits which were paid under a Cigna disability policy.  Dave worked for Purdue University as a Health Desk Technical Support Supervisor until he became disabled and eligible for disability benefits under the Cigna policy.

Facts of the Case Against Cigna

After over 18 years of employment at Purdue University, Dave was forced to stop working when he became totally disabled due to Seizure Disorder and the resulting symptoms from this disorder.  As you can imagine, seizure disorder can be difficult to prove with objective tests because there are very little signs of the seizures unless they are actually occurring.  However, Dave’s treating physicians provided objective medical proof that he was unable to continue working due to his seizure disorder.

The O’Ryan Law Firm has represented numerous employees of Indiana University (“IU”) who have become disabled because of serious illnesses such as chronic pancreatitis, lymes disease, degenerative disk disease, ovarian cancer, and osteoarthritis. A large number of those clients were employees who had worked for Indiana University for many years, some even decades, before reaching the point where they were no longer able to work because of their medical conditions.

Indiana University’s Long Term Disability Plan is an income replacement plan for IU employees who become disabled due to an illness or accident[1].  The following are the general terms of the long term disability coverage provided to IU employees:

  • With claim approval, the plan pays a regular monthly income when an enrolled employee becomes disabled.

O’Ryan Law Firm recently filed an appeal for Long Term Disability benefits against Liberty Life Assurance Company of Boston (Liberty Mutual) for wrongfully denying a participant’s benefits. The client was a long time employee of a large financial institution and was forced to stop working due to coronary artery disease, hypertension, diabetes, and ischemic cardiomyopathy. The client underwent a coronary bypass in 2010 and had a dual-chamber cardioverter defibrillator implanted in 2015. He suffers from shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pain, and experiences confusion. The high level of stress with the client’s occupation exacerbated the symptoms correlated to his illness. This stress exposed him to a possibility of a severe cardiac event or even death.

Despite the client’s treating physicians providing objective medical proof that he was unable to continue working full time due to his condition, Liberty Mutual hired a contracted physician to review his claim file. The hired contracted physician contended the client could perform a Sedentary occupation on a full time basis. In addition, the hired contracted physician erroneously claimed the client’s treating physician could perform a Sedentary occupation on a full time basis. When in fact, the treating physician never released the client to return to work full time.

Liberty Mutual originally approved the short term disability claim in full, but then turned around and denied his long term disability benefits based on the hired contracted physician review. In an attempt to solidify the client’s denial, Liberty Mutual hired a private investigator to perform surveillance. The private investigator failed to observe any real activity for four entire days, which was consistent with the client’s limitations. Liberty Mutual cited the following definition of “Disability” within the long term disability denial letter:

O’Ryan Law Firm, on behalf of Plaintiff, William M., recently filed a federal lawsuit against Lincoln National Life Insurance Agency (“Lincoln”).   Lincoln is an Indiana corporation with its main headquarters in Omaha, Nebraska.  William M. was employed by Olon Industries, which made him eligible for Olon Industries’ employee benefit plan.  Part of the employee benefit plan included long term disability coverage which pays 60% of an employee’s salary if an employee becomes unable to work due to sickness or injury.  Lincoln National agreed to insure the long term disability benefits and provided this coverage to the Olon Industries employees.

William M. was employed by Olon Industries until he became disabled in May 2012.  He became unable to work due to a severe stroke, intracerebral hemorrhage, hypertension, permanent vertigo, and partial blindness in his right eye.  His treating physicians provided objective medical proof that he was unable to continue working due to these medical conditions.

Lincoln paid Plaintiff’s claim for disability benefits for 24 months, then they abruptly terminated the benefits with little notice.  Plaintiff internally appealed Lincoln’s decision and in November 2016, Lincoln upheld their decision to deny Plaintiff’s long term disability benefits.  William M.’s doctors never returned him to work even though he was 4 years past his stroke.  As proof that he remained disabled, the Social Security Administration recently reviewed Plaintiff’s claim, and after sending him for a medical exam, concluded that he remains disabled.

The O’Ryan Law Firm recently represented a former employee of Trinity Health, in South Bend, in a lawsuit against Hartford Insurance Company.  Plaintiff worked for Trinity Health as a Food Service Manager for 24 years when she was forced to stop working for Trinity Health because she became disabled in July 2014 mainly due to chronic daily severe headaches.  Hartford Insurance provided disability coverage to Trinity Health employees agreeing to pay income replacement benefits to any employee who became disabled due to injury or illness.

Plaintiff applied for her disability benefits offered through Trinity Health’s employee benefit plan, and insured by Hartford. Hartford approved Plaintiff’s claim beginning in December 2014.  More than 12 months later, on January 12, 2016, a letter from Hartford informed Plaintiff that her benefits would cease on January 13, 2016. In the January 12, 2016 denial letter, Hartford stated, “We have determined that the weight of the medical evidence in your file does not substantiate functional impairment which continues to prevent you from performing Your Occupation on a full time basis. Therefore, benefits are not payable beyond January 12, 2016 and your claim has been closed effective January 13, 2016.”   The Hartford policy has the following definition of “Disability”:

Disability or Disabled means you are prevented from performing one or more of the Essential Duties of:

At the O’Ryan Law Firm, we have represented several clients who have become disabled due to the severe symptoms of Schizophrenia.

According to the National Institute of Mental Health[1], schizophrenia is described as follows:

Schizophrenia is a chronic and severe disorder that affects how a person thinks, feels, and acts. Although schizophrenia is not as common as other mental disorders, it can be very disabling. Approximately 7 or 8 individuals out of 1,000 will have schizophrenia in their lifetime.

According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention[1], Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (CFS) is described as follows:

Chronic fatigue syndrome, or CFS, is a devastating and complex disorder. People with CFS have overwhelming fatigue and a host of other symptoms that are not improved by bed rest and that can get worse after physical activity or mental exertion. They often function at a substantially lower level of activity than they were capable of before they became ill.

Besides severe fatigue, other symptoms include muscle pain, impaired memory or mental concentration, insomnia, and post-exertion malaise lasting more than 24 hours. In some cases, CFS can persist for years.

O’Ryan Law Firm, on behalf of Plaintiff, Denise D., recently filed a lawsuit against The Prudential Insurance Company of America (“Prudential”).   Plaintiff was employed by Advance/Newhouse Partnership, which made her eligible for the Advance/Newhouse Partnership Short Term and Long Term Disability Plans, which were administered and insured by Prudential.

Facts of the Case Against Prudential

Plaintiff was employed by Advance/Newhouse Partnership from 2012 until she became disabled in February 2016 and was unable to work due to lupus, fibromyalgia, migraines, spondylosis and radiculopathy. Plaintiff’s treating physicians provided objective medical proof that the Plaintiff was unable to continue working due to these serious illnesses.  Her physicians also confirmed that she was unable to perform the material duties of her job thus meeting the definition of “Disabled” under the Prudential policy.

O’Ryan Law Firm recently settled a lawsuit against American United Life Insurance Company (“AUL”) on behalf of a client whose long term disability benefits were prematurely terminated by AUL.   AUL is headquartered in Indianapolis and has their main office in downtown Indianapolis in the AUL building.  The client, Candace, is actually a New Jersey resident so naturally it would make sense to file the claim in New Jersey.  However, the O’Ryan Law Firm was able to represent Candace in Indiana because of the fact that AUL is incorporated under Indiana law.  As a result, AUL may be sued in Indiana and the lawsuit was therefore filed in the federal district court for the Southern District of Indiana.

Case Against AUL

Candace was employed as an accounts manager for an insurance brokerage company from 2008 until she became disabled in December 2012.  She became unable to work due to lumbar radiculopathy and moderately severe cervical stenosis, both of which resulted in chronic pain and fecal incontinence. Her treating physicians provided objective medical proof that the she was unable to continue working due to these medical impairments.